Perfect Popcorn Recipe #3 ~ Surprisingly-Good Seasoned Popcorn

Every time I take this popcorn to a gathering, someone asks for the recipe and it came about as a complete mistake. Glad it turned out to be a good mistake!

We LOVE popcorn.

Plain popcorn, nut buttery sweet popcorn..basically every which way including our specialty, Dorito® popcorn.  We LOVE it.

But as a whole foodie family, we do not love the icky chemical fake stuff that most popcorn toppings are made of.

Ads by Healthy Ads

Well, great things often come as the result of mistakes.   That includes great popcorn seasoning recipes. :-)  Like this one.  It just might be the best popcorn topping you have ever tasted.

Yes, good things often come from mistakes.  Just like Chat Masala, our family’s beloved Indian seasoning, which came about when I mistakenly mixed spices in the wrong proportions. (It’s amazing and if you haven’t tried it yet, hop on over there and do so.)

Well, for you trivia buffs, here is part of an article from Associated Content on other great inventions that were the result of mistakes, one of them being penicillin.

Amongst all of the above mentioned inventions, penicillin is the best invention ever created by a mistake. In 1928 Scientist Alexander Fleming decided to go on a vacation without cleaning his workstation. On returning we saw a strange fungus on some of his cultures. He also noticed that the bacteria didn’t thrive close to those cultures. Till today, penicillin is one of the most widely used antibiotics in the world.

You can read about a bunch of other mistaken inventions in this article.

Now, I for sure do not expect that my seasoned popcorn “invention” will make it into the next Associated Content article, but I will say that it has been a huge hit wherever it has been served.  And I mean it.

Wherever we take this popcorn (and we take it EVERYWHERE), people ask us for the recipe.  I’ve even been told it is seriously addictive.

This great popcorn seasoning originated one day when we were preparing popcorn to take to an outing.

We’ve been avoiding gluten (so pretzels are out of the question [except for the gluten-free ones that cost a small fortune!]) and we avoid MSG type stuff and artificial cheezey flavor that is on simply every variety of Doritoes and such snack foods.  Our third-tiered snack food concern is GMO corn.

I am not as hard-lined about this as I am about the other issues that I just mentioned, but I really like to avoid regular corn chips for that reason.  So, if we are going somewhere where there will likely be lots of “not OK snack foods”, we often bring our organic popcorn.

Well, you might remember from my Perfect Popcorn Recipe #2 post that we usually top our popcorn with a special blend of Herbes de Provence with added garlic and onion.  On this particular day, however, our well had run dry — (meaning our container of popcorn topping was empty) and I mistakenly pulled out a similar container and proceeded to top our popcorn with–

Homemade Vegetable Broth Mix!!

Well, being the Charlie Brown type personality that I can be sometimes, I was quite discouraged, but as it turned out I had come upon a culinary advance for all mankind :-).  Surprisingly Good Popcorn Seasoning was born.

Here’s the recipe.  You can also visit my post on Vegetable Broth mix for other tips on using the mix and additional time and money saving tips as well.

By the way, many of the following links are affiliate links. If you click on them and make a purchase, I might make a commission. Your support is much appreciated and helps keep this free resource up and running

Oh – and in my opinion, the best way to pop popcorn is in this handy dandy crank handle stainless steel popper:


So, the next time you are hunkering for some yummy organic popcorn, try topping it this way!

Want some more great popcorn snack ideas?  How about:

And don’t be afraid to experiment in the kitchen!!  The results may surprise you!

And if you are looking for a good place to get spices, try Frontier or Mountain Rose Herbs.  I personally like Frontier’s quality better, but Mountain Rose Herbs has organic spices at bulk prices and you don’t need to buy a ton to save!

More Wholesome Snack Recipes:

Silky Smooth Bean Fudge
Homemade Protein Bars
Low Carb Oat Muffins
Healthy “Almond Joy” Bars
Homemade Marshmallows (sugar free option)

What is YOUR favorite healthy snack?


    Speak Your Mind


  1. This is my first time here. Found you through Frugal Friday. You have tons of great homemade tips. I’ll be browsing for awhile. I started a new link-up on Wednesdays, Kitchen Economics: Cost Cutting Tips to Save Money in the Kitchen. I would love for you to stop by next Wednesday.

    Thanks ~ Kristia

  2. Found your post through Facebook and so glad I did! This sounds really wonderful and my kids would love it. I’m going to search through your site for the Herbs de Provance recipe too :) Thanks for the inspiration!

    • Hi Sarah!

      I am sorry, but I didn’t get the recipe posted yet for Herbes de Provence. Thanks for the reminder and hopefully I can get it done soon :-).

  3. Catherine says:

    I must tell you though, that in our gluten free world, most of us in our family actully like gluten free pretzels even more than the regular ones. Just an fyi. :)

    • Hi Catherine,

      Yes, we like the gluten-free pretzels too, but we mainly avoid them due to their cost (ouch!) and the fact that they are made almost entirely of starch and we are trying to eat whole grains. That being said, they are tasty! Thanks for stopping by!

  4. This sounds like it could be really good! I think I have most of the spices so I may find some popcorn and even try it tonight.

  5. Right now, alot of my family is sensitive to corn, but for the future, how do you prepare your popcorn? On the stove? With an air popper? Thanks so much!

  6. I cannot wait to try this. We love popcorn and are looking for a healthier way to eat it. Come over and visit us. We have a terrific apple sausage recipe to share.

  7. This recipe looks really interesting. The flavors seem as if they go together well. I will be trying this Friday for our weekly Friday Movie Night. I linked to you from These Chicks Cooked. Thanks for a great recipe!

    • Teri, I hope you like it! There’s another great one on my blog too. Wherever we take them they are a huge hit. We are always asked “What’s on this popcorn?!”

  8. Hi Adrienne! Wow this recipe sounds delicious and perfect for movie night. I’ve tried making popcorn at home once before, but all my popcorn ended up burning. Any tips?

  9. Adrienne,
    When my husband is having his “big bowl” of ice cream every night, I am having my pop corn. I will sure be trying your seasoning it looks great. Thank you so much for sharing with Full Plate Thursday and have a great week!
    Come Back Soon,
    Miz Helen

  10. This sounds so good! I’m going to have to try it. We eat popcorn more than any other snack.

  11. I love popping my own Popcorn on the stove, I will have to try this unique flavors, I bet it’s amazing.

  12. All-righty then, I’m sold! Thanks for sharing with us, Adrienne. :) ~Lisa

  13. Oh, I forgot to mention, great popcorn photo! :)

  14. Mmmm. Gotta love popcorn. This recipe takes it to a new level. Sounds like something my husband will love.

  15. This sounds delicious! I have a ton of popcorn sitting in my pantry, and I would love to make it more often. Thanks!

  16. yummy recipes :)

  17. We love popcorn. This will be fun to try. A little something different to a family favorite. TFS!

  18. Yummers! We love popping our own corn at home, and usually just season with sea salt and olive oil. This sounds pretty tasty! Next time I am feeling adventurous I will give it a go!

  19. I totally agree, mistakes can be wonderful things! No wonder everyone asks for the recipe for this popcorn topping – it sounds so delicious. Thank you for sharing it with the Gallery of Favorites.

  20. I INHALE popcorn! It’s my go to snack. I like to kick it up by adding spices to it either before or after I pop it on the stove depending upon the spice. I pinned this and will try it soon. Thx!

  21. Adrienne,

    I just stumbled upon your blog in searching for a natural popcorn seasoning. We are having a “movie night” at our business Wednesday night, and I decided to make popcorn, rather than buy it. I want something special for the popcorn, that would be appealing to all tastes. Would you suggest this recipe, or the Herbes de Provence? I always get a little nervous when I serve publicly;) Love your blog, and thanks so much.


    • Hi Nikki. Hmmmm….hard to say. I think they are both wonderful and they even taste great mixed. I don’t think you could go wrong. The only thing I will say is that the “special seasoning” one can be a little spicy if you include the pepper in it. My youngest is sensitive to spicy foods and he commented negatively to popcorn with the seasoning the first time that I put it on (when it had pepper in it), but he later asked for more :-). I don’t cook much with pepper because of him and because I have read that it is hard on one’s digestive system and we could all use a little bit of TLC in that area :-).

  22. Sorry to bother you again, I decided to go with the Provence blend, the only problem is that I don’t know how much salt to use! I can’t eat corn, so I can’t taste it, and I’m cooking for 20 other people that I’m trying to impress;) Could you suggest an amount of salt to add in the recipe for the Provence? I’m actually making the popcorn soon, so you may not even be available to answer.

    Thanks sooooo much!

    • Oh, you’re no bother….and you’re lucky. I was supposed to be out, but we missed a deadline :-). I just sprinkle it on top along with the spice mix. I have honestly never measured it :-). I think you’ll be fine. After I sprinkle both on, I toss the popcorn around a bit so that it coats all of the corn. I so hope they like it. We honestly take our popcorn everywhere!

  23. Thanks for the support;) Say a little prayer for me! I’ll let you know how it goes.

  24. It’s official — we don’t make nearly enough popcorn! This sounds really interesting and I’m sure that seasoning tastes great on all sorts of things. I’m a huge fan of making my own blends, partially because we’re in Germany and you just can’t get blends like you do in the US. And partially because they’re way healthier without extra unnecessary flavor boosters, and you can tweak them just the way you want them. 😉

    • I hope you like it Tiffany! Where are you in Germany? I visited Munich and Heidelberg in my- ahem – younger days. Saw Dachau too. Nothing to celebrate, but in my opinion, a must see.

      • We live near Frankfurt. It’s not one of those cities you need to visit…like Munich! 😉 My MIL grew up near Dachau and a lot of Germans refuse to go near the camps because they have been shamed for so many years. So I’ve never been there but always been interested.

        • Oh, I’m sure Frankfurt would be wonderful – I really enjoyed Germany. I honestly don’t think the Germans need to be ashamed. I think the Holocaust needs to be remembered. If the German people are sorry that is what matters. We all have the capability for that kind of evil in our hearts (to quote Corrie ten Boom). You should visit if you get a chance.

  25. Yum! I love a good popcorn recipe! I have a linky going on at my blog & would love for you to join in- it closes tonight.

  26. Thank you for your submission on Nourishing Treasures’ Make Your Own! Monday link-up.

    Check back later today when the new link-up is running to see if you were one of the top 3 featured posts! :)

  27. Sometimes kitchen mistakes really make for better food – I mistakenly spilled some falafel spice (bought at my favorite place in NYC Kalustyan’s) on my tuna salad many years ago and now we can’t eat tuna any other way. This sounds outstanding. Always trying to find a new popcorn recipe that I like. Lime and Chile is delicious but this sounds outstanding. Thanks.

    • Hello Risa. We used to make Chili Lime Popcorn as well. I must say, however, that this is a clear winner for us. Hope you think so too! I love falafel! Wonder about that mixture :-). It’d be great to be able to recreate it!

  28. You are so funny! I enjoyed reading this post as much as I am sure I’ll enjoy the veggie broth popcorn recipe! I’m so glad the Lord crossed our paths! I hope we can spend some time together in person soon! Are you going to Allume???

    • Hi Kelly! How are you!? I wasn’t planning on it….I’ve never gone to a blogging conference. I did see that you are. Have you ever been to one? I’ll have to check into it. I sure would love to get together. :).

  29. With this great amount of salt,my blood pressure would blow off my meter.

  30. Sarah Butcher says:

    for the corn sensitive people sorghum can be popped and is like a mini size it smoked when popped but no burnt taste to it.

    • I’ve seen that. Does it really work? I saw popped sorghum online and in a nearby Indian store. Looked great! Is it hard to pop yourself? Can you use a regular popper?

      • Sarah Butcher says:

        It won’t work with a “regular” air popper but any of the pot or pot stirrers will and somewhere there is a sorghum air popper. I think its amaranth but there is another grain that will pop too……..

        • Thanks, Sarah! I’ll have to try it! And a sorghum popper – sounds wonderful! Amaranth is the one that will pop but it is too small to work in my “stirring type” popper. Thanks!

  31. Hmm, looks yummy! I’ll have to give it a try, thanks for the recipe!

  32. Sharon Mervin says:

    Our grandsons love the WirlyPop corn maker too! It works great!
    By the way, have you ever seen Unique brand Sprouted Wheat Pretzels?
    They can be somewhat pricey also, but they are delicious. I am able to get them at one of the stalls in our Amish Farmers Market and they are cheaper thnt our two local health food stores

    • Haven’t seen those. I don’t typically buy anything pricey and processed. Can’t make myself – oh and we’re GF right now. My popper isn’t Whirley Pop b/c I found out it’s made of aluminum – I bought a stainless steel one instead. I love it! Thanks for sharing!

  33. Totally making this! Thanks for your endless supply of healthy, wholesome ideas for just about everything!

  34. Try topping popcorn with nutritional yeast (small flake) — it makes it taste cheesy – that’s our favorite way around here!

  35. I know this is not healthy, but we love our popcorn with butter and parmesan cheese.

  36. How do you get your spices to stick to the popcorn? When I make it , it falls to the bottom of the bowl.

    • If you put the spices on right after popping, while it’s still hot, the warmed oil will help it to stick. If you don’t use oil it won’t stick. Hope that helps!

  37. I use a hot air popper, now I know why. What do you think of spraying olive oil on it?

  38. Have you ever tried this seasoning mix on Kale chips? I’m just wondering if it would go well.

  39. Susan Wheeler says:

    This recipe iiis delicious. The only thing I did different the 2nd time around was after mixing it all, I put it in the small coffee grinder. It sticks better that way. I love popcorn, now it’s even better. Grassfed butter, organic non gmo popcorn(even better when the FM has some) and your own seasoning. Doesn’t get much better than that!

  40. We love nutritional yeast on our buttered popcorn!

  41. Thomas Nelson says:

    I really like this mix. I used an old spice bottle and keep a jar of it, as well as several other mixes. It’s good.

  42. Found this from Pinterest, but one question:
    WHY 6 teaspoons? Like obviously 2 tablespoons is the exact same thing and not nearly as obnoxious. Are you afraid your readers will confuse the 2 tablespoon ingredients with the 2 teaspoon ones? Have more faith in your fanbase if that’s the case.

    • Hi Taylor. Thanks for commenting. I think what happened is I multiplied the original recipe to make it a larger batch and didn’t happen to reduce the tsps to tablespoons — it was a mere oversight and had nothing at all to do with a lack of faith in my fanbase. I make mistakes and oversights sometimes :). I don’t see it as any more obnoxious than using 4 T instead of writing 1/4 cup (which I did as well). Perhaps you didn’t notice that. You are the first person to notice this in all the years this has been on my blog. Thanks for pointing it out and hope you enjoy it.

Simple Share Buttons