Why I Don’t Make Laundry Detergent
This post may contain affiliate links from which I will earn a commission. Learn more in our disclosure.
Homemade Laundry Detergent. It's one of those things that almost every crunchy mama makes, right?
Well, not this one.
You know by now that I get a real kick out of MYO (Make Your Own) projects, right?
My husband says I get this little mischievous smile on my face when I figure out a way to make something that we've been buying (or not buying because it is just way too expensive :-)), or even when I just think I'll be able to do so.
I really feel like I am beating the system or something.
Kind of like winning a mini lottery!
Making your own products can be a big help when you are trying to reduce toxins in your life.
Today I am going to tell you one thing that I do not make – and that is homemade laundry detergent.
Here's why.
Years ago (too many. I'd really rather not think about it :-)) when we lived in the Chicago area, we were living on very little money (ummm..like $13,000 per year). Let's just say that $13,000 a year doesn't go very far in Chicago :-)!
My oldest was born and I was forced to leave my job.
Well, really I chose to. My boss reneged on a work-at-home offer and so I quit, not wanting to leave my son with anyone else.
So saving money was a really big deal to me. Really big.
I was buying the loss leaders at the grocery store (we got a lot of funny looks and stares with our grocery cart full of 10 cent oranges or 10 cent yogurts :-)), buying nothing new, and we even lived with my inlaws for 2 years.
Anyway, I had a friend who made her own homemade laundry detergent and for some reason, it really mystified me.
I have no idea why, but there are sometimes projects that stump me for awhile.
I feel like I just can't get myself to do them for some reason.
Other things like that have been :
– making bread (I ended up with the most amazing whole wheat bread recipe – in our pre-gluten free days)
– making candy (I finally ended up learning how to make lollipops in our pre-sugar-free days)
– making lip balm or deodorant (this is coming soon!)
Laundry detergent was one of them. I would just buy an allergy-free brand at a local store and make it last as best I could.
Well, fast forward about 8 years to our home in Michigan.
I finally got up the gumption to make my own homemade laundry detergent.
I bought myself some Pure Kirk's Castille Soap (because those recipes featuring Fels Naptha just wouldn't cut it for this all natural gal. That soap has colors and chemicals and a pretty intense artificial fragrance that really throws me for a loop. Ick.
I grated that soap (I think my grater is permanently soap flavored now), heated it all up in my now soap-flavored calphalon pot (:-().
And used it.
And hubby wasn't happy.
Maybe it was the lack of fragrance, but he really wasn't happy with what was going on with his t-shirts.
And I didn't like making the soap. I got pretty depressed when I saw the bucket was almost empty.
So I tried something new that I am going to introduce to you today – soap nuts!!
What? Nuts that make soap?
Yes. Really. And they work (i.e. no more complaints from hubby). Actually, it's the hulls that make the soap. Pretty neat eh?
And it's more than just interesting, it's good for your wallet.
First, let's talk about what soap nuts are and how to use soap nuts.
What are Soap Nuts?
From Naturoli's website:
soap nuts are the dried shells (or husks) from the soapberry (or soap berry nut). These berries are the fruit from a quite unique tree species. These shells contain a substance called saponin that produces a soaping effect. Saponin is a 100% natural alternative to chemical laundry detergent and cleansers. It can replace many chemical detergents such as those containing sodium laureth sulphate (SLS) that are becoming well known by consumers for being a skin irritant and health hazard.
NOTE: Soap nuts are not nuts – they are fruit. So even if you have an allergy to nuts, soap nuts should be just fine for you :).
Why I Love Soap Nuts
1. They are all natural – no chemicals going on my clothes, on my family's skin, or into our environment.
2. They are very reasonable. Just pennies per load, especially if you buy the larger bulk sizes.
3. They are super easy to use! And my pots and graters don't end up tasting like soap!
4. The resulting used-up soap nuts are compostable :-)!
5. Soap nuts leave no smell. I mean, I like nice smelling things, but this way, all you get is clean.
How to Use Soap Nuts
Yes, it's pretty weird using nuts in your laundry. But they are really easy to use and no, you won't end up with nut butter in your laundry :)!
1. Put 4-5 soap nuts in a small muslin bag (you buy some of these with your soap nuts).
2. Put a large clip on the bag (this is my handy dandy idea – keeps that soap nuts bag closed tight and keeps it from getting lost in the wash.) I LOVE the large Twixit Clips for this purpose. See below for more info on these great clips!
3. Toss in the washing machine before your clothes go in.
4. Remove from laundry after washing (Naturoli tells me it's really OK to dry them if you miss this step!)
5. Re-use 3-5 times. Well, truth is I use mine about 6. Cheapskate frugal mama! Told you I like to save money.
6. The above directions are for a warm or hot water wash. If you are going to wash in cold water, soak the soapnuts in a cup of hot water (from the tap is OK – thanks for the tip, Katie of Kitchen Stewardship…Silly me – I've been heating water in a pan. But then, especially in the winter it can take awhile for our water to heat up) for about 3-8 minutes prior to use to activate the saponin.
Below is a handy dandy photo of my tiny bag of soap nuts secured with the Handy Twixit Clip and my “heavy duty” plastic container that I use:
More Tips on How to Use Soap Nuts:
1. The biggest tip in my mind is using the Twixit Clip on the bag. Otherwise, I can only imagine how many lost soap nuts bags I'd still be looking for (they're not very big!) You can use the Twixit Clips for so many other things around the house that it's great to buy the whole set even if you're only using one for your Soap Nuts bag. You can see more ways I use them in my posts on How to Store Nuts and Seeds, The Easiest Way to Freeze and Store Berries, and Easiest Sun-Dried Tomatoes. No more pesky twist ties!!
2. I use about 6 soap nuts because I have a front loader and it washes a bigger load.
3. Use a heavy duty container for pre-soaking your soap nuts if you are using cold water for washing. I once decimated a plastic container since it couldn't stand up to the hot water :-(.
4. After loading the soap nuts into the washing machine, I set the plastic container on top of the washer. Then when the load is done I just find the little bag (with the help of that big clip) and drop it in the container, all ready for the next wash.
5. When it's time to pre-soak the nuts, I just fill up the container with water, drop it in a saucepan, heat it up and pour it back into the container. Wait a few minutes and run it down to the laundry machine.
6. You can tell the soap nuts are done when they look grayish and are falling apart. Sometimes this frugal mom tries to get just one more load out of them though :-)!
7. Thanks to a reader asking….soap nuts can be used in HE machines.
Why I Use Naturoli's Soap Nuts
There are a bunch of soap nuts companies out there. I spent a bunch of time researching them (what else is new???) and found that though other brands are cheaper, they may not be real soap nuts. They may not clean as well and they are sometimes not deseeded, meaning that they weigh more.
That means you are paying for the seeds as well which do not do the cleaning. For me, I chose to purchase these since they appeared to be of great value and I have been pleased with them.
Another Homemade Laundry Detergent Alternative
If you are giving up on making your own homemade laundry detergent (like me) and you would like another option besides soap nuts, then here are some other options.
We are using Ava Anderson's Laundry Pods and are very pleased with them. They are super convenient (just toss one in the back of your front loader) and do a great job.
Update 1/16: I left Ava Anderson due to many labeling issues and wrong / missing ingredients in products. I've been on the hunt for a new laundry product and I LOVE this laundry ball!
Super easy to use and it lasts for 365 washes!
Other DIY Household Products
So….I don't make homemade laundry detergent, but I do make…….
Homemade Foaming Soap
Amazing No Streak Glass Cleaner
Simple Natural Dishwasher Rinse Aid
Plastic Wrap Substitute (well, not really :))
Update on Soap Nuts–aka Can You Have a Soap Nut Allergy?
So, I feel kind of funny adding this BUT–years after writing this post, 2 of us in the family had reactions to soap nuts.
Online it seems that a soap nut allergy is really rare and even some soap nut companies seem to say that it's not possible, but we definitely had reactions. It might have been something on the soap nuts, but I could never figure out what that was, so we just chose to avoid them after that.
So I went on a hunt for a good natural homemade laundry detergent formula again and found it. I also also developed this DIY Baby Laundry Detergent that's great for sensitive skin needs too.
Whatever you prefer–Homemade Detergent or Soap Nuts or store-bought, please just do your best to avoid the toxins!
Have you ever used Soap Nuts?
I have several old mesh bags for washing delicates in the washer. Would they be OK to hold the soap nuts? They are large–about a foot square.
Yes, that should be fine – until the soap nuts break apart. Sometimes they break into fairly small pieces when they get used up.
I’m so glad to find this information. I just discovered your blog today.
I have chemical sensitivities, so I can’t use most laundry products. Even the dryer exhaust from next door makes me a little sick. For years, I’ve used Charlie’s Soap, which worked well enough for all our laundry and didn’t make me sick. But my dog got very old and incontinent, so I tried homemade soap (castile soap, washing soda, borax) and found it worked better on the tough stains and odors in the dog items. I add a little extra borax for the worst stains. Our water is slightly hard, and I think that makes a big difference in how difficult it is to get clothes really clean.
I’ve been using the homemade stuff for dirtier items for a few months, and using up the Charlie’s on things that are easier to wash. I have few whites, and care nothing about dinginess–I use things until they fall apart whether they are stained or not. Don’t know if I’d be unhappy with the homemade stuff if I wanted bright whites.
I was planning to stick with homemade soap long-term, but soap nuts are intriguing. I still have one dog and a cat, and there will always be tough stains to get out, so I’m concerned whether the soap nuts are good at that. If they save money over what I’m doing, I’m all for trying them.
I wouldn’t say the soap nuts are great at stain removal – but I use a DIY stain remover for that. I’ll have to find the recipe and share sometime :-).
aka Why I use Soap Nuts: Affiliate Commissions
My laundry detergent is made from homemade soap, borax, and washing soda. It works as well as any I’ve ever used, fits your conditions, and is about $0.03 a load. Don’t see the benefits of spending the extra money here.
Hello Al. I was going to just delete your comment, but thought I’d best reply. First of all, I am wondering if you read my post. I shared that I tried my own DIY detergent and didn’t care for it. That being said, I am glad that it works for you and I wish it did for me.
Secondly, I would like to clarify for you and for all of my readers. I never have – and never will – recommend something just in order to get affiliate info. Yes, I make income from links to Naturoli. But honestly, I have been an affiliate with them for about 1 year and just have never posted about the soap nuts I have used for more than that amount of time. I write about things and recommend things that I make no money from, but I will not be a sell out.
I spend a ton of time on my blog and care very much about my readers and about what I share with them and what I recommend. If you want evidence of that, read my post on Which Essential Oils are Best. I have been laboring over this post for a long time trying to sort out what to share b/c I know it is very important to people.
The affiliate links and advertising and other ways I have to make money with my blog just help me keep it going and help me to pay for alternative care for myself and my family. It is a home business for me, but one that I take very seriously. I am saddened that you would make such an insinuation in your comment that I use soap nuts in order to get affiliate income. Please take care in the accusations that you make in the future but I do hope you come back and share in the future. I wish you had been more kind, but I welcome honest inquiries and would have been happy to tell you all this had you just asked kindly.
Thank you again.
In regards to your response to Al all I have to say is “Well done, Andrea!”. I stopped here to read about these soap nuts and, I must say, I’m very intrigued. I’ll need to do my own research (not because I don’t trust you but because *I’m just that way* ;o)) I’m going to see what you have to say about essential oils as I use Young Living brand (yes, I am a distributor but it’s mainly because I want the wholesale pricing!) and I agree with you wholeheartedly about only recommending something that you use and are happy with. Love your site!
Thank you Diane. I so hope to have the oils post done soon. I am almost there :-). Thank you so much for the kind words. They mean so much. Oh – my name is Adrienne, so I was thrown off a bit by your comment but thank you anyway :).
I have heard about soap nuts and wondered how effective they were. It’s great to hear you have had such good results with them.
I love this idea. Any ideas for the dishwasher?
I have a natural rinse aid up but no luck on detergent yet :(.
I’ve never heard of soap nuts in my entire loooong life.
Thanks for the tip.
Over from the Fence…
Okay, I loved this post not only because it reminded me of a post I wrote about homemade laundry detergent (Link deleted by Whole New Mom due to it not working anymore.), but also because I ended up learning about soapnuts, which I might at some later point try.
I’m so glad I found you at the Christian Mommy Blogger Friday link-up.
God’s peace and good to you.
I’ve been looking into soap nuts. I heard that they leave line-dried fabrics softer than normal detergent. Does anybody have any experience with that? I love line drying my diapers, but they end up SO crunchy when I take them down!
I recently read that a little white vinegar in the rinse will soften clothes. You could try that and see if your line-dried diapers are softer. The article said to use 1/4 cup vinegar but I think a half cup would be OK, too. I have used as much as 1-1/2 cups vinegar in the rinse with really dirty items.
Thanks for this post. It was an attention-grabber on the Hearth & Soul Blog Hop. 🙂 After my Etsy-sourced laundry detergent is gone, I think I’ll give soap nuts a try again. With a baby on the way, I’m all for saving some dough (and our skin!).
Maybe it’s our water or with my middle school boys, crafty girls, messy baby and coaching husband our clothes are too grungy, but nothing was clean when I used Naturoli soap nuts. I wanted so badly for them to work for us, but no luck. I have tried making my own detergent using Kirk’s Castille Soap, but ended up using it to scrub toilets.
Does well water vs city water make a difference in soap nuts?
I don’t think water makes a difference unless it’s super hard. Do you feel you are getting great results w/ what you are using?
I am getting fantastic results with what I am currently using (Norwex), but found out that it has a small amount of brighteners so I need to switch to something else. Sigh. I loved that I needed only 1/2 tsp per load and it got most stains out without pretreating.
I need something that really cleans everything from football pants to cloth diapers and doesn’t cause my littlest one’s eczema to flare. I’m having trouble finding the “perfect” detergent. It has been awhile since using the soap nuts, maybe I could try again.
Hmmm…Maybe just try a little bit and see how it goes. I haven’t ever been one to go for “super clean” – just getting the job done and costing not too much. But the homemade detergent was just a big flop. Take care.
I used the soapnuts for awhile too. I found that my whites just would not get white and I couldn’t ever get any stains out. Our clothes just didn’t get “clean” very well. I put up with it until I used up a pound and I still use them on my delicates or anything for babies. Now I make my soap and I’m much happier with the results I get. I know we have very hard water here in Texas so maybe that makes the difference. 🙂
I’m not sure – I guess there are other things that might make a difference. Our water is borderline hard. Maybe I could try your recipe :-). I use a homemade stain remover for stains. I don’t really rely on my detergent to do that and never have.