Which Saves the Most Money – Dehydrating, Freezing or Canning?

This post may contain affiliate links from which I will earn a commission. Learn more in our disclosure.

Pinterest Hidden Image

With the cost of food going way up, many are choosing to buy in bulk and store up food for the future.

But what’s the cheapest way to preserve food? Should you dehydrate, freeze, or can your food; is one method much less expensive than the others?

Read on; you might be surprised to learn the answer!

peaches in jars and frozen vegetables in bags collagePin

Over the years, I’ve gotten a lot of questions about saving money while eating healthy. And some of those questions have centered around food preservation.

For example, one reader told me that she wanted to purchase a dehydrator and/or a freezer, but her husband wasn’t sure about the cost savings. Once you add in the expense of the appliance and the ongoing cost of operating it, it’s hard to know what the end cost is.

Doing food preserving on your own certainly gives you control over the procedure and the quality of the food, and it is a great step towards a more “whole foods” oriented lifestyle, but we all want to know that we can save money while doing it as well, right?

Well, I did a little digging around and found a fabulous resource that outlined the costs of food preservation and I thought I’d share the information with you.

Food Preservation Cost Comparison

Of course, costs have changed since this post and the book I’m referencing were published, but the information and conclusion are still interesting.

Freezing:

frozen vegetables in freezer bags.Pin

Freezing is also a great option for storing up food. And there are so many things you can freeze. Check out these posts for some great examples:

Estimated cost – 16.2 cents/pound

Equipment Needed: Freezer @ $270 amortized over 20 years* = $13.50/year

Repairs: 2% of purchase price = $5.40/year

Packaging: $25.00

Electricity: To operate freezer at 5 cents/kilowatt hour = $35.28
To blanch 250 pounds of food (4 min/pound) = $1.99

Total to process 500 pounds of food: $81.17

Canning:

canned peaches.Pin

Estimated cost – 5.5 cents/pound

Equipment Needed: Pressure canner @ $65 amortized over 20 years* =  $3.25
Water bath canner @ $10 amortized over 20 years = $0.50

Repairs: 2% of purchase price = $1.30

Packaging: 24 dz quart jars @ $4.39/dz amortized over 10 years = $10.53
24 dz lids replaced each year @ $.49/dz = $11.76

Electricity: To pressure can 140 quarts at 5 cents/kilowatt hour = $1.44
To water bath can 140 quarts =  $2.22

Total to process 560 pounds of food in 280 quarts: = $31.00

Dehydrating:

sliced tomatoes on dehydrator tray.

Dehydrating is one of my favorite ways to preserve food, and there’s so much more you can do with a dehydrator too.

Before we get into the costs, here are some posts showing how we like to use our dehydrator:

Estimated cost – 4.8 cents/pound

Equipment Needed: Electric Dehydrator @ $190 amortized over 20 years* = $9.50/year

Repairs: 2% of purchase price = $3.80

Packaging: $500 one-pound plastic bags = $2.50

Electricity: For drying food = $6.50
For blanching 250 pounds of food (4 minutes/pound)= $1.99

Total to process 500 pounds of food: $24.29

(*If the equipment is used for less than the full amortization period, the cost per pound of food increases significantly.  Also, if smaller amounts of food are processed, the average cost per pound will increase.)

The above information comes from page 5 of Preserve It Naturally (2010), a book about dehydration that you can purchase from Excalibur Dehydrator.

The data I use above are from the book, but the costs of energy, equipment, etc. have clearly changed and will vary according to your personal situation, i.e. your energy costs and how good you are at finding bargains on packaging, etc.   Still, I think this is an eye-opening comparison.

Individual situations aside, it’s clear that dehydrating and canning are extremely cost-efficient ways to store food.  Of course, that doesn’t mean that freezing isn’t a great option either. 

If it costs 16.2 cents per pound to freeze something and you can secure the type of deal that I did at a local store about 4 months ago when we got grass-fed lamb for about 3.25 / pound, then paying an extra 16 cents per pound still makes the lamb a great deal. 

Also, there are just some things that lend themselves better to one form of preservation than to another.  For example, I don’t want to can or dehydrate meat or chicken broth, but those items both freeze quite well.

So, I think I have now put my inquisitive mind to rest.  And I’m feeling pretty good about our second fridge, chest freezer, dehydrator, and even about the second chest freezer that we plan to buy later this week.  Bring on the sales; I have room to store the surplus! 

Some Posts About Freezing

If you don’t have a dehydrator yet, I wholeheartedly recommend the Excalibur Dehydrator, but a blogger friend of mine told me that she has this dehydrator and loves it. I am definitely going to try it out based on the reviews and the fact that it has stainless trays!

I Recommend

COSORI Food Dehydrator

The Cosori dehydrator has 6 stainless steel trays (instead of plastic), a timer, and a glass door so you can see how the dehydrating process is progressing without opening the machine. 

A Helpful Dehydrating Book

Here is a great book to get to learn more about dehydration, and it has tons of recipes in it.  I don’t own it yet but plan to get it soon.

Another Option: Freeze Drying

Since initially writing this post, another option for food preservation has come onto the scene–Freeze Drying.

I hope to add the cost comparison here in the future, but it will for sure be the highest, with the trade-off being that the food retains an amazing amount of nutritional content, tastes like “the real thing” when eaten, and lasts a very long time.

This is the freeze dryer that we have. We need to branch out more with what we preserve but it’s great to be able to freeze dry guacamole when avocados are on sale. Freezing avocados is an option, but freeze-drying is SO much better.

Did you expect dehydrating to be the cheapest way to preserve food?
Which food storage methods do you use?  

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 

169 Comments

  1. I’m hoping to find someone to share a dehydrator with this summer. I really want to turn some of my tomatoes into “sun-dried” tomatoes but don’t want to have to store and keep a dehydrator all year.
    I just started canning. Out of all three methods, I think the amount of time invested in canning should be considered in the cost. It is far more time consuming than freezing or dehydrating.
    I couldn’t live without my freezer for the meat as you mentioned. Buying quality proteins on sale is my biggest money saver.

    1. I completely agree with you on the canning thing re: time. One thing to consider…you can store your dehydrator wherever. I have mine tucked into a corner of our pantry and another blogger I know has hers in the basement next to her grain grinder! Believe it or not, I used to have mine in the living area off of our dining room. Now that’s a weird whole foodie for you :-).

  2. Thank you for your cost analysis of freezing, canning and dehydrating for food preservation. I can and freeze a lot, but now I must reconsider dehydration!!

    1. You are welcome! Do you have a dehydrator already? I can get you a great deal if you need one. But you’ll have to teach me how to can though :-).

  3. Great post and information; I’ve been canning food for more than 40 years and it’s always new and exciting. I love it when others decide they want to be in charge of their pantry; well done!

  4. First time reading you through your link Simple Lives Thursday. I like this comparison. Don’t forget about root cellar storage though. Oh my goodness, it is the best for a lazy/busy person like myself. 🙂 I toss butternut squash, other winter squashes and apples in my cellar for months. How easy is that? And, no cost either.

    1. I would LOVE to root cellar things! I live in an area that has a really high water table, is flat, and my home, built in 1945 was not built well, hence the foundation is cracking and peeling cement….yuk! Also, there is about 18 inches between the floor and the dirt underneath, AND in rainy season {which, so far, has eluded us} it is full of water!…. So… no root cellar for me….. ;-(
      Someday, WHEN I can afford it, and all the other important things have been done here on my 5 acres, I will bite-the-bullet, and do a new foundation for $40,000.00 or so, THEN I’ll have my root cellar!
      I envy you a bit on yours! 😉

  5. Thank you for the interesting comparisons. I use a combination of methods depending on the food, but I prefer canning. Electricity is unpredictable here during hurricane season. We could be without power for a week when a storm blows through which is pretty much the end of your freezer stash. It’s also very humid here most of the year. Dehydrating food is an uphill battle when the humidity is high. So, I stick to canning for the most part. Thanks again for the great information.

  6. Where did you get the canning jars at that price? Here in the Atlanta area they are double that amount.

    1. I mentioned in the article that I didn’t purchase these items – they were prices quoted in the book and the book was published initially a number of years ago. Obviously, prices vary by location as well and you can always get your things for close to nothing at garage and rummage sales, etc. I do know that here, around canning season, that Menards has canning supplies very cheap with an in store rebate :-).

  7. Thanks for linking to our frugal tuesday tip. i love to see cost comparisons like this.

  8. Don’t forget about culturing as an option! Not very time consuming, using your own recycled jars. Requires salt and cold storage, plus optionally whey or vegetable starter culture.

    1. Great idea! I was focusing on the major forms of preservation on people’s “radar” — also, for some reason I am not tolerating fermented foods right now so I have not been pursuing this currently. Thanks for the reminder!

      1. I wonder what would cause an intolerance? Too much detoxing? It is good to use ferments in small quantities at first. I cultures almost entirely with salt only and, since the cultured bacteria is naturally occurring in the digestive track, most people shouldn’t have a problem. Too much die off from detox overload can definitely be a problem, however.

        1. My current thinking is that it is an allergic reaction as I have candidiasis and metal toxicity that I am working on. The practitioner whom I am working with thinks I should hold off for now. I was soaking grains and having reactions. I am pretty sure that that is what it was. I am not willing to experiment again, but maybe after awhile and when life calms down a bit.

  9. I also can, freeze and dry. Different things need different treatment and depend somewhat on what I want the particular product for.

    Did the book you used talk at all about the various nutritional implications of the methods? I would find that very interesting.

    Chris

    1. This topic was touched on briefly. It was mentioned that dehydrated food retains more nutrients than methods of food preservation that heat the food (of course, this depends upon not turning the temperature of your dehydrator up too high — They obviously don’t go up to a very high temperature in any case). According to the book, removing the water from foods causes some loss of Vitamins A & C, which can be minimized by proper processing.

      1. Where was this touched on briefly? I didn’t see it either. I have always read that freezing was the best to preserve nutrients?

        1. In the comment section perhaps? Sorry – I am totally swamped here. If you didn’t see it in the comments then I can try to find it for you – thanks!