Homemade Flavored Liquid Stevia Drops
This post may contain affiliate links from which I will earn a commission. Learn more in our disclosure.
Do you love Liquid Stevia Drops but don't love the price? Here's how to make your own Homemade Liquid Stevia and save loads of money, PLUS you can make flavored liquid stevia this way too!

I've been using stevia for a long time now–ever since I knew that I had candida. I personally think that stevia is safe and I think you can grow to like it even if you didn't when you first tried it.
It can be hard to know how to use it, but here's a guide to help you use stevia to get you inspired.
One of my favorite stevia products is liquid stevia drops.
They are little dropper bottles full of flavored liquid stevia that you can add to your favorite beverages (like sugar-free lemonade and coffee substitute) and sweet treats (like raw brownies and almond joy® bars) without
- feeding candida or
- adding calories
I love them and with the amazing variety of flavors out there you can really go to town.
The only problem is, they are really pricey.
Thankfully, there's a simple way for you to make your own homemade flavored liquid stevia easily!
Flavor Options
There are endless options for flavoring these drops. Truly the sky's the limit.
You simply use whatever extract or natural flavoring you'd like your liquid stevia drops to be.
While I love all of the flavors that I've tried, vanilla liquid stevia remains one of my favorites.
I've used it in my Healthy Coffee Substitute and it can be used to sweeten any beverage.

How Much Will You Save With These Homemade Drops?
The cost of liquid stevia drops varies, but one thing is sure; you will save a lot of money.
This vanilla liquid stevia from NuNaturals currently costs $12.52 on Amazon.
This one from Sweet Leaf costs $9.09.
The total cost for my 2 oz bottle?
It's a little variable and took some intense calculating to figure out, since I purchase my stevia in bulk but here goes:
- Stevia extract (I currently use this brand): $1.03
- Vanilla extract (I used this brand. Here is another brand with no sugar.): $1.05
- Dropper bottle (mine was free since I saved a leftover one from stevia, but you can purchase one on Amazon (this is a handy-dandy set of 6 dropper bottles, so you can make all kinds of stevia drop blends.)
By the way, stevia is pretty hard to measure since it's so concentrated. These stainless steel mini measuring spoons from Amazon are super handy. The 2nd smallest is the size of 1/32 of a teaspoon, which is the typical size of a scoop that's included in most stevia containers.
If you don't want to buy a 1 pound bag of stevia extract, here's a one ounce container.
Total Cost of This Homemade Liquid Stevia
Without dropper bottle: $2.08
With dropper bottle: $3.58 (plus shipping on the bottle, of course, but you can reuse it.)
So if you don't need a bottle, you can save up to 84% by making your own vanilla liquid stevia.
At these savings, I guess you won't be buying any more liquid stevia drops, eh? Well, with a few exceptions.
There are some flavors that would be pretty hard to replicate. One of them is this really great Root Beer Flavored stevia drops.
Add these to sparkling water and you've got a great Sugar-Free Root Beer!
Recipe Notes and Substitutions
- Stevia Brand: I link to NuNaturals stevia in the recipe card since that is the brand I recommend in general, but a few readers have said that NOW stevia works well for this recipe and their stevia is quite a bit cheaper, especially in the one pound size.
- Stevia Crystals: I've gotten a few reports that some people get stevia crystals on their dropper after making this and placing it in the fridge. I'm not sure why that is, but hopefully we can figure it out.
- Stevia Flavors: If you'd like your liquid stevia to have a different flavor, you can try different extracts in place of vanilla. Options include: chocolate extract, cherry extract, lemon extract, peppermint extract, and butter flavor. I haven't tried any of these, but I think they should work!

Homemade Liquid Stevia Drops
Ingredients
- 1/4 cup water
- 2 1/4 teaspoons stevia extract (The amount you need will vary by brand)
- 1 teaspoon glycerin (optional but recommended)
- 7 teaspoons vanilla extract (or other natural flavor/extract)
Instructions
- Pour water into a small saucepan.
- Warm over medium heat. Add stevia extract.
- Heat and stir until stevia is dissolved.
- Remove from heat. Add glycerin and extract if desired.
- Pour into a small glass bottle with dropper. Note: There will be a little too much to fit into the bottle. Just keep it in another bottle or container and use it first. I chose these measurements for ease of use.
- Store in the fridge.
Nutritional information is provided as a courtesy and is an estimate only. It may vary depending on ingredient brands, substitutions, and preparation methods. Optional ingredients are not included. Net carbs are typically calculated by subtracting fiber and sugar alcohols (such as erythritol) from total carbohydrates. This information should not be relied upon for medical or nutritional purposes.
What's your favorite way to use flavored liquid stevia drops?
What's your favorite flavor?




Wow this is an excellent savings! I found you on Thrifty 101; wanted to follow you but I don’t see a follow button; would love for you to visit. I’ll be dropping by often.
Thanks! Did you mean follow on email, RSS….? The follow links are all at the upper right. Would there be a more easily noticeable place? Thanks!!
I do this all the time and sometimes add some cinnamon into it too !:)
Any idea how to make it using an actual stevia plant?
Yes. Post forthcoming. I was offered stevia plants just yesterday – not sure when I’ll get them.
I came over here for this awesome tip but I am already excited about perusing the rest of your great ideas!
Thanks and Welcome! Hope to see you around again!
You can purchase small vials of candy flavoring at a cake supply store. Jo Ann’s and Hobby Lobby usually have some too. They have flavors like toffee, butterscotch, orange, etc. They probably would work to make other flavors, I’m just not sure how healthy the ingredients are. Probably artificial flavorings.
I am sure they are all or mostly all artificial. I’m going to have to work on this! Thanks!
Wow! I’m so impressed that you figured out how to do this. Well done, and thank you so much! I would be VERY interested in a “from plant version” as we live overseas. I can get the plant really inexpensively, but I only know how to use it in tea. I don’t know how to use it in baking so I am always having friends bring me extracts from the States. Thanks again!
You’re welcome! Just got an offer of a stevia plant so hopefully we’ll be at it soon!
this is excellent – I used to get a a green tea stevia blend that was about $20+ – I’m going to try that with your recipe!
Oh I love you!! Thanks ever so much for sharing this awesome recipe. I’m on it! =D
You’re so sweet. Enjoy!!! Hope to come up w/ some good flavors later!
Brilliant Adrienne! I am going to share this.
Thanks for sharing, Laura! I couldn’t believe how easy it is!
This is sersiously cool! I have a pretty big stash of liquid stevia at the moment (plain, vanilla, chocolate and english toffee lol) but when one runs out I am soooo making this! I will totally appreciate those cost savings 🙂
You’re welcome! I like the English toffee…I’m thinking there must be a way to make it so I’ll try my hand at it. Thanks!!
Any luck with English Toffee flavor?
Oooh – not yet but I have an idea!!!! Thanks for sharing this. I will try it!!