Did you know that there can be dangerous levels of heavy metals in cosmetics? It's a real concern that you should be aware of. Here's what you need to know about this serious problem and what you can do about it.
I've been concerned about heavy metal toxicity for a long time, but I never thought about heavy metals in cosmetics. I mean, I've know about mercury in fish and in fluorescent light bulbs, and lead in paint, but heavy metals in makeup?
It's true.
For years I have seen different natural practitioners for things like candida, thyroid disease, adrenal fatigue. And several times a practitioner would mention mercury or other heavy metals as being an issue. I didn't really know what to think.
I got my mercury fillings removed (even though I didn't have many and they were really small), and took zeolite which for sure showed that I had some kind of heavy metal problem (when I took it, my urine smelled like metals for two weeks), and later did a program that was supposed to help my body release the metals on its own. I'd also heard about chelating metals via an IV, but was pretty concerned about the safety of that method.
One thing kept bothering me…..
Where was all of this metal coming from?
Heavy Metals
Lead, Arsenic, Cadmium, and Mercury are the metals that are of the greatest concern and they are linked to all kinds of health problems.
When you think about heavy metals, typically you think about their presence in water, soil (we got our soil tested when we planted our gardens), cigarette smoke, paint (lead), vaccines, and fluorescent bulbs.
One thing I never thought of was my foundation or my mascara.
Would you believe that heavy metals might be lurking in your beauty products?
I wouldn't have thought so either, but it's true.
Heavy Metals in Makeup
Mercury has been found in skin whitening creams (1 woman apparently had 100 times the average amount of mercury in her urine!) (Source [1]. Lead, cadmium, chromium, manganese, and aluminum have been found in lipstick and lip glosses (some in very unsafe levels). Basically, in all kinds of color cosmetics, heavy metal contamination has been discovered. (Sources: [1] [2] [3] [4])
Regulation of the beauty industry is basically non existent. In fact, here in the U.S., the federal government hasn't passed a law to regulate ingredients in beauty products since 1937 (yes, you read that right). (Source)
Even if there were “safe” levels determined for these products, when you add up the exposures that most women get between multiple beauty products and other exposures (think the air, water, food, bulbs, etc. listed above), then toxic levels can be more easily reached.
Changing My Cosmetics
Now, I'm not a big makeup kind of gal, but I've worn a little throughout the years, and as I've gotten older I've worn a bit more –some foundation, an eye pencil and some mascara.
About 3 years ago I started switching over to more natural, organic products, and even tinkered with a few DIY versions.
It's been a long road, trying many brands. And revisiting some again and again to really figure out what I like.
I'm glad that I have found some products that work for me, without sacrificing my health.
What You Can Do
Basically, you need to get informed.
Know what's in your products and know your manufacturer.
And what about DIY / Natural / Organic Cosmetic companies?
If you've been around Whole New Mom for awhile, you know that I LOVE making almost anything from scratch, from coconut milk to weed killer. Well, I love the idea of DIY personal care products too. I make my own Eye Makeup Remover, Body Wash, and Hair Rinse, and even bought the ingredients to make my own face powder and foundation this past year.
But now I am not so sure I'll be using it. In fact, I just sent the manufacturer an email asking about heavy metals in the iron oxides, etc. that I purchased to see what they have to say.
Because mercury, lead, arsenic, cadmium, and more–they're all natural products. So even if your products are “natural” or “organic” or DIY, if they have metals in them, they can still harbor dangerous heavy metals inside at unsafe levels.
1. Skip the Color Cosmetics – well, maybe.
If you want to completely avoid heavy metals, you just might have to avoid color cosmetics completely and skip the whitening creams too. Whitening toothpastes have also been known to have heavy metal contamination / ingredients too.
To be as safe as possible, skip the foundation, the blush, the eye pencil, the lipstick, the lip gloss, the mascara, and the eye shadow. Unless you can find a line of products that uses only plant-based colors. Keep reading…..
But if you, like me, want a little color on your face, then you need to do your homework.
2. Check Your Products for Safety
Go to Environmental Working Group's Skin Deep directory to see what is in your products. Keep in mind, however, that only ingredients are listed — not contaminants. So what is listed on the label is only part of the picture.
3. Buy from a Safe Company
Contact different companies and see what they have to say about heavy metals and their products. Ask if they batch test and what the presence is of heavy metals in their products.
I buy my cosmetics from several companies, since I don't think that one size really fits all, unless you're talking an umbrella :).
But most of my makeup comes from Beautycounter.
Beautycounter tests every single batch of their products for the presence of heavy metals — they're that serious.
This is the language that appears on their site, describing their standards:
At Beautycounter, we third-party test ALL of our color products for heavy metals before we bring them to market. We strive to achieve undetectable levels of heavy metals in our products (undetectable level ranges from 0.5 to 5 parts ?per million, depending on the metal). We only proceed with shades that do not exceed our extremely low “allowable thresholds” for background heavy metals.
Believe me, in the world of color cosmetics, that's a lot of testing.
And beyond that, not only are their standards high, but their makeup performs fabulously.
Christy Coleman is a world famous makeup artist, and she is behind all of the cosmetics at Beautycounter. She's done covers for Teen Vogue, Elle, Glamour, and more. She knows what looks good.
Her goal is to have Beautycounter's makeup to be good enough for the runway, and perfect for every day as well.
And it is.
Beautycounter's mascara is practically waterproof without being toxic!
I once got caught in a downpour while wearing Beautycounter's mascara, and it didn't run one bit! (That's really something for the Queen of Smudge — that's me :).)
Beautycounter's lipstick is the only one I have ever been able to wear. My personal faves are Petal and Twig, with Terra being a close third.
Beautycounter also has a fabulous 60 day return policy, so you can buy without risk. And I bet you'll love your purchase.
Here is a very informational graphic showing the concerns of heavy metals in cosmetics, as well as how you can avoid the dangerous risks.
{Please note that the information about 2 ppm on the infographic should instead read .5 – 5 ppm as noted above.}
Read more here about what I love about Beautycounter.
No matter where you shop, make sure you do your homework and keep the heavy metals off of your face — 'cause no one needs that stuff in their makeup.
What brand of cosmetics / beauty products do you use?
What do you think about this?
Thanks for this article. I would like to testify that I am a sufferer of lead poisoning through cosmetics..namely lipstick. I was sicker than a dog…actually my brain was. My brain was to the point of being very inflamed and I couldn’t sleep or concentrate. I was told I would achieve psychosis if I would keep wearing this. My integrative Dr. did a heavy metals test and my lead was literally off the chart. I suspected lipstick and started looking up the brands I used and the colors. I have a job working with the public and so I was constantly putting it on. Immediately, I bought lead free and some other “free” lipstick. Also, I did DMSA chelation for 3 days and liver cleanse for 11 days. UPloading lots of nutrients during the time of the liver cleanse. That I did for 4 months. I still have to have a follow-up metals test. Trust me, you don’t want to have lead poisoning!
BTW…I did not eat 1000’s of tubes of lipstick….
Yeah, wow. I almost never wear lipstick but I can imagine how much one would ingest when putting it on on a daily basis round the clock. How fast did you go through tubes?
HI Adrienne, They didn’t last as long as they used to for some reason, however, I always bought at discount stores and clearance. It didn’t matter if it was Lancome or Revlon or other name brands. Bad stuff. The lead-free I bought lasts a long time, i.e. a few months.
There are no words to describe what my brain went through. I also had some IV vitamin and mineral treatments during this time.
Thanks for responding!
No kidding! That’s is so weird! You mean that the tube didn’t last as long or the lipstick didn’t?
I can totally imagine. I have been through so much myself. Finally coming out of my own nightmare. It’s multi-faceted as many health issues are but thankful I’m seeing some real solid progress now–the best I have seen in a very very long time.
My pleasure!! Glad to have you here and hope to see you around again!!
You are so welcome. Thanks for reading and for commenting. I’m so sorry that you went through all of this. I’m glad you are doing better!!!!
HI again, Sorry…I meant the liptstick with the poisons in them didn’t last as long. The tube/container was fine. I was always able to find name brands for $1.50 -$2.00 whereas purchasing lipstick with “less” in it costs anywhere from $14.00 up. Thankfully, it lasts longer. Have a great weekend. I am happy you are starting to see healthier days also. I could write a few books…
Yes, I am sure we could share a lot of stories. We might have a “story” starting with our youngest now. Sigh. If you are ever interested in trying out the Beautycounter brand, I’m happy to connect with you about that. I am going to start a FB group and I have a newsletter list as well for more nice things. It’s so nice to have a company that I can really trust! Feel free to reach out here or via email at wholenewmom {at} gmail {dot} com. Take good care!
Great info here Adrienne,
I was shocked when I heard that traces of lead were found in many popular lipstick brands. Some researchers claim we’d need to eat 1000s of lipsticks in order to develop lead poisoning. But why risk it when we don’t have to?
I’ve heard great things about Beauty Counter – I really need to check them out! I’m glad their standards are so high. I’ve also heard a lot of praise about 100% Pure’s lipsticks.
Thanks for recommending the Skin Deep directory. I also think consumers should learn as much as possible about ingredients (and potentially harmful natural products like heavy metals too) to stay informed.
Thanks again for recommending Beauty Counter – can’t wait to try it out!
Laura
Hi Laura – thanks for reading! I am really disturbed by heavy metals in makeup, especially in something like lipstick b/c of course we are getting these things from other sources too so you can’t just talk about what is in the lipstick and say that it’s safe. I would love to stay in touch w/ you about this. I don’t allow self promotion on my site so I did remove your link, but we should talk for sure! 🙂
I just received an email promoting metallic make up and I found it scary, so I googled ‘metals in make up’ and saw this article. There are certain metals needed by your body during the metabolic process and during respiration and they are there by nature. When you start adding these heavy metals they get absorbed into your blood stream and over a period of time, problems ensue. I guess most people don’t realise that the skin has blood vessels and that’s how it gets its nutrients. This explains why a lot of people who use these make up on a regular basis look way older than their age. If the FDA is not involved, maybe it should look into it and protect consumers. People seem to care more about animal products in cosmetics when they should pay more attention to the toxins we put in our system for the sake of looking ‘ beautiful’. Thanks for your article.
You are so welcome. Yes, you are right about the heavy metal implications on health. Not sure about people using makeup looking older but that’s interesting. Beautycounter is trying to to do what it can. Hard to know how much to have the government do since gov’t oversight can be a problem, but in this case I think it’s needed. Thanks again!
Hi Adrianne, have you any updates on 100% pure?
Yes I had a lot of back and forth with them. They sent me some products to sample and I signed up as an affiliate. However, the hair products smelled very very strong so I asked why since the label said only “coconut” on it. They initially told me that it was coconut essential oil but that doesn’t exist. Finally, after a long back and forth they said it was heat extracted coconut extract. My understanding, after talking w/ a skincare expert, is that there is no such thing but I can go back and check. She said that there is another extract but it’s very expensive and not that strong so you would have to use a lot of it to have an intense smell.
I smell the same smell but I think stronger in Shea Moisture and both products make my chemically sensitive son react badly. I can’t use them and I can’t in good conscience recommend them so I removed them from my blog. If you are looking for other options please reach out to me here or via email. Thanks for reading.
Hello again and thank you so much for your quick answer. I have started to read, the gather and check a huge ammount of info with hope to find a 100% natural, non-toxic and not harmful cosmetics.its all started after I’ve been pregnant and since than Im really struggling to find a company I can trust. I’ve been cheking every single ingridient in order to find something i can you with no worries and the only one that seems to use only natural ingridients Was 100% pure.
I really dont know har to do at this point ‘ cause not to use make-up it isreally NOT A OPTION, cant immagine to go out with no make-up ?
Serious company should take its clients seriously and what you experienced it si really dissapointing me…. is it possible you have been taking to somebody who doesnt have that kind of knowledges and is just responsable of communicatin etc?
Anyway, do you have any advices for me? Please tell me the company who really cares and produces a 100% natural (no chemicals, synth.stuff and so on) exists ?? A
Hi there.
No I was talking to customer service and then the affiliate manager who got the information right from the company. I have a few options for you. Here is one: https://wholenewmom.com/araza
I haven’t tried their products yet, but they are very clean. They haven’t assured me of batch heavy metal testing so in that sense I would lean towards Beautycounter.
Here is another. https://wholenewmom.com/credobeauty
This one has a LOT of brands and many are not as clean as you seem to want, but the RMS brand would meet your needs I think. Again, I don’t know of any company that batch tests for heavy metals but I think these would be good options to consider.
Hope that helps!
thank you one more time, I will check these links
I have tried to quickly check some of the products on beautycounter , so far cant find something I can cosider really clean ((
You are very welcome. I understand your thoughts about Beautycounter. They do not purport to be organic or all natural. Their aim is to be much safer than mainstream skincare and beauty products while performing at a high level. Their head of creative design, Christy Coleman, is well known for her talent and her contribution to the company yields color cosmetics that are simply lovely.
I hope that clarifies :).
Sorry to disturb you that much, but would you be so kind to answer just one more question about 100 % pure? Do you know something about their certifications for heavy metals of if they ? There is a long story on their site about how they test for this and that but no word about heavy metals. Thank you and sorry for taking your time.
So greatfull for your help and happy to know someone is doing such a great job as you do
I have no knowledge that they do any of that kind of testing. They state on their site that they don’t have synthetic colorants and mention that they can contain heavy metals. However, iron oxides, etc can as well and they do mention that their products do / might contain those. They have a lot of products so I haven’t gone through all of them. Thanks for the kind words!
Hi, what do you think about the 100% Pure makeup company?
I am trying them out soon. I used their eye cream in the past and that didn’t work well for me, but trying other things next. Have you tried them? Thoughts?
UPDATE 5/18/17 I will not be recommending their company for various reasons.
Hello there. Update – I am digging into them and am having issues with their fragrances. I can’t get the answers that I need about them. I hope to have more information but they are saying that they have a heat extracted coconut extract in their hair products and I can’t find such a product anywhere on the internet so I’m stumped. I have talked to a soap company that didn’t understand either as well as another extract company so I want to talk to one more. It’s a puzzle and I’m not comfortable yet. I am happy to help with other companies but so far can’t recommend this one.