Strawberry Pesticides--the TOXIC Truth
Strawberries are delicious and loaded with antioxidants, but could the pesticides on them outweigh their health benefits? Strawberry pesticides are something that I didn't know about for a long time, but once I did, my thoughts about conventional strawberries changed dramatically.
So the question is--what strawberry pesticides are being used, are they seriously dangerous or not that bad? And do you need to buy organic only or grow your own?
Strawberries are particularly vulnerable to pesticide contamination since they are grown in the soil, are really vulnerable to pests, and they have no outer peel that you can remove.
Houston, we have a problem.
You think you are helping your family eat healthier by having them eat fresh fruits, but not so fast. You serve them strawberries since berries are one of the fruits that are lower in carbs, and you add some strawberries to a morning smoothie, or you make this Berry Chia Pudding, these Gluten-free Strawberry Scones, these Strawberry Popsicles or this Sugar-free Strawberry Lemonade.
But instead of giving your family health producing foods, you could be literally killing them with toxins.
What Strawberries Are on Pesticides Exactly?
What's On My Food is a fascinating site showing details of pesticides found on both organic and conventional produce, the type of toxicity associated with each pesticide, and what other foods commonly have that pesticides on them. I warn you, however, reading what is on that site will cause you to never want to eat conventional produce again.
That page shows a list of the forty-five (yes, that's 45!) pesticides found on strawberries in their most recent tests. Yikes.
Here's the list:
Combining Pesticides Makes Them More Dangerous!I don't know why that is since EWG states clearly that Captan is cancer-causing and has been banned for use on certain crops by the US government. Then why is it on my strawberries??!? (source)
For example, the site lists Tetrahydrophthalimide (Captan) as being the pesticides (it's really a fungicide) that was found the most on strawberries, in 55.3% of conventional strawberries. And yes, it's still being used today. For some reason, however, the site doesn't list toxicity concerns for this product.Tetrahydrophthalimide / Captan FungicideTheir information, however, is not totally accurate. Things might be worse than they seem. (Is that really possible?)
The other thing that isn't documented on What's On My Food, or on many sites at all, for that matter, is the fact that pesticides (and other potential toxins) are almost always studied ALONE--not in conjunction with other toxins.
It's well known that some things work better with other things. Iron works best when taken with vitamin C, turmeric seems to work best when paired with black pepper (so you might want to add some black pepper to this Adrenal Fatigue Tonic), and guess what? Pesticides can be more toxic when combined with other toxins.
According to this study, the resulting oxidative stress-related enzyme gene expression increases appeared to show that together, pyrimethanil, cyprodinil and fludioxonil did more damage than they do on their own. Well, what do you know--those 3 pesticides were all found on strawberries.
What I find to be most disconcerting is that What's On My Food didn't list any toxicology concerns for cyprodinil, but the Coleman, O'Neil, et al study, said:
Cyprodinil was the most toxic agent individually!
all three agents showed significant reductions in cellular ATP, at concentrations that were more than tenfold lower than those which significantly impaired cellular viability. The effects on energy metabolism were reflected in their marked toxic effects on mitochondrial membrane potential. In addition, evidence of oxidative stress was seen in terms of a fall in cellular thiols coupled with increases in the expression of enzymes associated with reactive species formation, such as GSH peroxidase and superoxide dismutase.
Huh? Can someone tell me what is not toxic about that????
Risks of Strawberry Pesticides
Out of the 45 pesticides listed on What's On My Food, there are:
- known carcinogens (they cause cancer)
- endocrine disruptors
- neurotoxins, developmental or reproductive toxins, and
- bee toxins as well.
And just in case you think that endocrine disruption doesn't sound as scary as carcinogen, anything that is affected by hormones is affected by endocrine disruption, and endocrine disruptors can cause cancerous tumors. Ugh.
In addition, aside from the above risks, prenatal pesticide exposure has also been linked to reduced IQ of children. (source)
Now that list is from 2009, so things may have gotten better, right? Yes, but things are still bad and there are a lot of places to see just how bad it is.
More Recent Strawberry Pesticide Data
In 2017, in a single study by EWG, one single sample of conventional strawberries found 20 pesticides on the fruit. (source)
In 2016, federal examiners found that 98% of all conventional strawberries had pesticide residue. (source)
In 2008, in Australia, testing results found:
- Levels of pesticides over the allowed amount
- Pesticides that weren't allowed in Australia
- Organic strawberries that contained residue of the fungicide pyrimethanil, but based on the amount it's thought that it was contamination from other crops. This underscores the importance of taking precaution even when buying organic! (source)
Some Good News
I guess that one of the only good things I can say about strawberry pesticides is that one horrid pesticide, methyl iodide, is no longer being used in the US on strawberries. What's sad about this is that Canada stopped using this toxin in 1987, but it took until 2012 for the US to catch up. (source)
Here's a very disconcerting quote about methyl iodide. I shudder to think of how much of this toxin myself and my family may have eaten over the years.
"Everyone agrees, without exception, that methyl iodide is a very toxic compound. It's very reactive. That means it interacts with living tissue in very toxic ways, causing cell damage and damage to cell structures, DNA, or chromosomes," explains Ted Schettler, MD, MPH, science director at Science and Environmental Health Network.
"The upshot is it can cause a lot of health effects, including cancer and damage to tissues that are developing. In animal studies, it killed the fetuses of developing animals exposed by inhalation; fetuses were killed at relatively low doses. Nobody doubts it's a nasty chemical." (source)
Talk about a toxic messola. Thank goodness at least one ingredient in the toxic soup has been removed.
Aren't There Pesticides on Organic Strawberries?
Some people make the argument that there are pesticides used on organic produce as well, so you might as well save money and skip spending extra for organic.
Does that make any sense?
There are several posts on the internet making such claims but from the information above, it's clear that this is NOT the case and that there are simply LOADS more toxic pesticides on conventional strawberries than on organic ones.
These articles state that companies like EWG are not evaluating things in an appropriate manner. They refer to this kind of information as the basis for their claims:
While conventional produce was between 2.9 and 4.8 times more likely to contain detectable pesticide residues than organic produce, samples of organic produce frequently contained residues. The PDP data, in fact, indicated that 23 percent of organic food samples tested positive for pesticide residues. (source)
Yes, there are still pesticide residues, but as you can see on What's On My Food, there as less and sometimes none of certain pesticides on the organic produce.
Basically, here is the deal. Do you want more toxins, or less? More endocrine disruptors, carcinogens, reproductive toxins, or less?
I know what I want.
Some More Good News--Pesticides on Frozen Strawberries
Thanks to a tip from one of my super smart fans on Facebook, I found out that frozen conventional strawberries have fewer pesticides than fresh!
The reason for that is that since the strawberries are meant to be frozen quickly, they are grown with that intent. Since they won't have to stay fresh as long, so there are fewer chemicals sprayed on them during the growing process.
So if you're going to eat conventional strawberries, choose frozen and not fresh!
Sugar-free Strawberry Smoothie anyone?
Can You Wash Pesticides Off of Strawberries?
The answer is yes--and no.
According to this study, you can wash some pesticides off of strawberries, but the amount that is removed depends on what technique you use.
Boiling is mentioned in the study, but boiled strawberries aren't really tempting.
You might note that in the study, tap water was one of the cleaning methods used--resulting in a reduction of 19.8 - 68.1% reduction of the toxins. However, that's a HUGE range! Why is that? And how do you know that you are getting closer to the 68.1% off and not the 19.8%?
And also note that the study only tested for 10 fungicides and 6 insecticides.
Remember that here, there have been 45 (yes forty-five!!) pesticides found on strawberries. Again, that number has likely changed since then, but there have been more than 16 cited in recent years.
And remember that the above test only tested for 16, so you can't claim that there is a reduction if many pesticides weren't tested for in the first place.
Pesticides IN Strawberries
Also, there are some toxic pesticides and herbicides that are actually IN the produce that you eat, since they are taken up in the plant through the roots while it's growing. This is similar to glyphosate, that horrid toxin that has even been detected in our water and our air.
It's simply impossible to get away from it. As a side note, our family is currently using this supplement that has been shown to remove glyphosate from the gut while rebuilding gut villi. You can see the preclinical trial results here. You can use code wholenewmom to get $50 off your first order and try it for yourself.
Options for Removing Pesticides from Produce
Soap and Vinegar
Another produce-washing technique has been to put a small amount of non-toxic dish soap and white vinegar in water, soak the produce, and then scrub if possible. However, I always wondered if it was really working at all. We do buy organic whenever possible, but even so, there are pesticides on organic produce too.
Baking Soda Soak
Some research has been done showing that soaking in baking soda and water. This article highlights how soaking in baking soda and water removed 2 pesticides from produce. However, there are a lot more than 2 on the foods that we eat. Still, it's promising.
When I initially wrote this post, I mentioned that most people wouldn't have an ultrasonic cleaner or ozone device in their house, but things like this are becoming more common.
Since then, I have come across some great options for cleaning produce. For example, this ozone water device is fantastic. Soaking produce for 20 seconds addresses many issues including bacteria, mold, and pesticides.
Another option is HOCl and KOH.
You can buy this device to make these at home. Use code wholenewmom to get 5% off and another 6 months on the warranty. First soak in the KOH and then the HOCl to address pesticides.
Strawberries and pesticides are topics that very much need to be addressed.
No wonder there are so many cases of auto-immune disease, autism, cancer, thyroid disease, and more going on today. When I was growing up, it was pretty much unheard of, especially with children, but these days, it's becoming commonplace.
With all of these chemicals barraging our bodies and the toxic buildup that ensues, what else would anyone expect to happen?
Our bodies are fearfully and wonderfully made and our creation was made perfect. I'm not against everything big business, but the slovenliness with which some companies use toxins just to make things simpler, or make their bottom line a little better at the expense of our health, makes me sick. Literally.
This information about strawberries and pesticides is enough to make your head spin, but let's keep our heads on straight. Let's plow ahead, deciding how to make healthy decisions for ourselves and our families.
What Can You Do?
- Buy Organic Strawberries whenever possible
- Wash strawberries really well.
- Consider a produce wash, however note some studies show that using vinegar or baking soda works well.
Have you been eating organic or conventional strawberries?
After reading this, do you plan to change?
I really liked your site. Thanks for the information.
Thank you for the informative article. We eat home grown and organic fruits and vegetables but recently bought strawberry cider without thinking. I would like find a company who would test produce/products for consumers. The search is daunting to determine which is the most common to test and where there is affordable testing. Any suggestions?
Hello Mark - thanks for the kind words! Are you wanting a company that will test for pesticides or for other things as well--just for one test or ongoing?
The USA agricultural/produce sector has been very diligent in lobbying the decision makers within the NHI, FDA and USDA to keep info that is harmful to consumer consumption buried deep under the rug. I don't eat ag-chem grown strawberries, peanuts, melons, etc. The article above does NOT state that strawberries, peanuts, melons, tomatoes, potatoes etc. absorb toxic ag-chemicals because these are water soluble toxins sucked up by a plant's route system as it grows. BUY ORGANIC!!!!
Why is there not a ban or recall on strawberries if they are so bad and filled with toxins? It seems like there would be a pubic health investigation like the e coli outbreak on romaine lettuce earlier this month. Any insight into why public health is not involved with the strawberries?
Because this is the way that food is treated these days. E coli isn't supposed to be on the romaine but the farming industry considers pesticides to be a necessary thing. The powers that be think that these toxins aren't that dangerous. Sad, but true. Trying to raise awareness here.....we'd love to have you join in the work :).
Adrienne, thanks so much for the post.Really thank you! Great.
Thank you so much! This was actually a very old post that I had to go in and redo and I learned soooo much digging around. Glad to know that the hard work was a help to others!
Thank you for you time and yes I do appreciate ALL your efforts and research and facts. Several years ago I had read about strawberries among several others like zucchini and spinach, Jake as well for the big bad pesticides and have only purchased organic believing I was buying on the safe side... Well now I know better be and will most definitely purchase the cleaner, cc thank you.
I think you meant just as well, and not Jake, correct :)? I agree - no way on the conventional for me either!
There is no way I would consider buying conventional strawberrries-Never! I knew (and felt) they were one of the worst produce products out there, and have been buying organic berries for many years, but WOW what an eye-opener! Thank you for your time in writing and informing us. It's sad. I remember going to my G-ma's house picking and filling my stomach with fresh berries of all sorts. Those were the terrific toxic free days. I'll have to look into the cleaner you mentioned. I've been cleaning my produce as you have and I've also been using Branch Basics with great success. Thank you my dear for your time and research. I'm truly grateful to you!
Thanks, Joyce! I was really impressed w/ what I read about that cleaner but I haven't heard back from them yet about what else they remove or if they have tested for anything else. Not sure how Branch Basics works w/ produce. Thanks again!!
I didn’t realize that there were so many! Thank you for the info. We, as a group have to make a stand against this.
Thank you so much - I was pretty shocked myself. I am sure there are some things that are needed but the really toxic things need to go!
I need good Peppermint oil for my sinus problem.
Hi there. Did you see this series? https://wholenewmom.com/health-concerns/natural-remedies/the-great-essential-oils-showdown-in-search-of-the-best-essential-oils/ That should help.
what about frozen strawberries
Genevieve, no matter frozen or fresh, organic is for sure the way to go. I don't eat them (or let my kids) if they aren't organic or no sprayed.