DIY Eye Makeup Remover (Natural Recipe & Simple Oil Options)

This post may contain affiliate links from which I will earn a commission. Learn more in our disclosure.

Pinterest Hidden Image

This DIY eye makeup remover recipe is gentle, simple to make, and works even on mascara and eyeliner. After trying several formulas, I developed one that removes makeup well without stinging or leaving a heavy oily residue. It’s truly the best eye makeup remover that I’ve ever used.

In addition to that, I’m also sharing simple oil alternatives and the formulas I tested that didn’t work well and why.

jar of make up removerPin

Many store-bought removers contain fragrance, preservatives, and other ingredients some people prefer to avoid. If that’s you, you’ll love the simplicity of this formula, in addition to loving how well it works.

Why This DIY Eye Makeup Remover Works

This formula is a simple one, but it works extremely well, and here’s why.

  • oil dissolves eye makeup, including waterproof mascara. It also reduces the stinging that plain witch hazel can cause.
  • witch hazel helps cut the greasy feel and residue from the oil
  • vitamin E is optional for extra nourishment
homemade eye makeup remover with jar of cotton balls and tweezersPin
jar of make up remover

Homemade Eye Makeup Remover

This Homemade Eye Makeup Remover works amazingly well and leaves no oily residue. It tested the best out of a variety of formulas that I tried. You're going to love it.
5 from 2 votes
Print Pin Rate
Makes: 0.33 cup

Ingredients

  • 2 tablespoons witch hazel
  • 2 tablespoons oil of choice
  • 2 tablespoons water
  • small glass jar with lid like this one or this one
  • organic cotton rounds or pads

Instructions

  • Add all ingredients to your container/dispenser.
  • Shake well before using.
  • Moisten cotton round or makeup pad with the mixture, or alternatively you can place some of the mixture on clean fingers, and then wipe eyes gently until all of the makeup is loosened.
  • Rinse your eyes with warm water.
  • Follow with water-based facial cleanser and your regular skincare routine.

Notes

  • To clean up stray eye makeup on face that might remain after using this remover, put a small amount on fingers or dip cotton swab in the mixture to clean up those marks.
  • When washing your face after using the remover, you will likely want to wash your eye area as well to remove any residue.
  • When using this remover for waterproof mascara, you will likely need to lightly massage it in a little bit more than you will for regular mascara.
  • SHELF LIFE: The witch hazel in this product will help a bit with bacterial growth, but you should only make enough to use within 3-4 days and store this in the fridge. If it smells off, discard. You need a broad spectrum preservative in this to keep it for a longer period of time.
  • I prefer using disposable cotton balls or rounds because eye makeup is difficult to wash off of washable pads.
Tried this recipe?Mention @wholenewmom or tag #wholenewmom!

This works so well that a natural-minded professional friend of mine—who is very particular about ingredients and demands performance from her products—told me this is the best eye makeup remover she has ever used. I always appreciate hearing that feedback, especially from someone like this.

How to Use This Eye Makeup Remover

  • Shake well before using.
  • Moisten cotton round or makeup pad with the mixture, or alternatively place some of the mixture on clean fingers, and wipe eyes gently until the makeup is loosened.
  • Rinse eye area and entire face with warm water.
  • Follow with water-based cleanser on face and eye area. If using a facial oil cleanser, you could do that first and then follow with a water-based cleanser for the double-cleansing method.

Simple Oils That Remove Eye Makeup

Some DIY makeup remover “recipes” online are simply a single ingredient, usually an oil, since oils dissolve makeup easily. Common examples include coconut oil, olive oil, almond oil, or jojoba oil for that purpose.

While I like facial oil cleansing because it removes makeup well, oils leave behind residue on eyelashes when used as an eye makeup remover. Even after washing once or twice, some oil can remain and cause the next day’s makeup to run or smudge.

Note that coconut oil can be too heavy for some skin types and may contribute to clogged pores for some people.

Castor oil is sometimes recommended in DIY makeup remover recipes or eyelash blends because it’s very conditioning and is thought to help with hair growth. However, its heavy texture can make it harder to remove from lashes and the delicate eye area. Some people prefer to blend a small amount with lighter oils, but I still find it too difficult to remove and prefer lighter oils for this application.

Homemade Eye Makeup Remover Recipes I Tried

While developing this formula, I tried a variety of options. Here are the results:

  • Witch hazel and oil: removed makeup but stung
  • Water, vitamin E, and oil: too oily and separated too much
  • Water, castile soap, and oil: stung and didn’t remove makeup well
  • Olive oil and almond oil: effective but much too greasy
  • Water and soap: stung and underperformed

Finally, after testing these options, I found that the above balanced oil-based remover with witch hazel was the perfect combination.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use coconut oil to remove eye makeup?

Yes, you can, but it can clog pores for some people. It also will leave an oily residue that can be hard to remove completely.

Does this remove waterproof mascara?

Yes, it works really well for waterproof mascara. You might need to massage your eyes a bit longer to get it off, but it will work.

Will this sting?

The oil in the remover is a buffer for the stinging. If you experience any stinging at all, it should be very mild. Of course if you have any kind of reaction to this formula, stop using it immediately.

How long does homemade eye makeup remover last?

Due to the water in this formula, you should only make enough for 3-4 days. The vitamin E might help it last a bit longer as will storing it in the fridge. If you want to make a larger batch, you’ll need to add a broad spectrum preservative.

Is homemade eye makeup remover cheaper?

Yes and this DIY version costs much less per ounce than store-bought eye makeup removers.

Prefer to Buy Instead?

If you’d rather not make your own eye makeup remover, here are a few brands I trust that have safer ingredients:

However, DIY options are far less expensive and allow you to control exactly what ingredients you’re using.

More Natural Beauty Recipes

Here are some more great homemade beauty products that are simple to make. I love all of these, and I think you will too.

What do you use to remove your eye makeup?

Photo Credits: Naomi Huzovicova

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




 

438 Comments

  1. I have been using straight up coconut oil as my eye make up remover for years and it works great and moisturizes, too.

    1. Hi Kristina. Several folks have mentioned that – but it wouldn’t work well to get stray makeup marks, would it? I think it would be way too greasy. I am also learning that straight oil seals – but doesn’t moisturize. So I am still trying to sort this out. Let me know what you think.

      1. To remove stray makeup marks, like mascara or eyeliner when your hand slips, try a bit of your normal makeup on a q-tip.

  2. Thanks for all the info from your experience! I love DIY natural solutions. Visiting form the Simply Designing Link Party.

  3. will have to try this- tried one with baby oil, tear free baby shampoo and water. it worked but I had to scrub a lot harder than I do with my makeup remover wipes that I usually buy. The wipes work so well, I’m not sure I’ll find a DIY solution quite as amazing..

    1. I hope you like it. I assume you mean store bought wipes? It’s so nice to be able to ditch the store bought stuff, you know? I mean, you still have to buy oil and witch hazel but you can use those for other things too 🙂

  4. I tried the “winner”. Too much oil. Couldn’t get it off and had a terrible day with my make-up melting. Could you look into an oil-free version?
    Thanks,
    Bev

    1. Really? Did you wash your face after using it? That was more of a problem w/ me with the straight oils. I haven’t found anything that is oil free. I think minimizing the oil helps a lot though.

  5. What a helpful post! My mother-in-law keeps a bottle of olive oil in her bathroom as eye makeup remover, but I’ve never tried it. I’d love to try your version! Found you from We Are That Family

  6. I agree with Michelle. Norwex makeup removing cloths are the way to go. They are made out of thin suede and you just get them wet with water, wring out and wipe away eyeliner, mascara and eye shadow SO easily! They are $20 for a package of 3 and you can use one about 4-6 times before you have to wash it. I have been using them for over a year and simply LOVE them!!! You can also use them to exfoliate/wash your face using just water and not all those harmful ingredients in soaps!

  7. Pure Raw coconut oil….best for skin, hair, removing makeup, cooking with, removing internal parasites and removing internal Candida.

    Beware of anything hydrogenated.

  8. I use olive oil and water, mixed that day. I haven’t thought of using witch hazel with it. It does get a little greasy, or messy, depending on how I apply it, but I tend to just rub it into my dry spots as moisturizer.

    Like I said though I mix in small amounts, just enough for that day, so I have no idea how shelf life is.

  9. This is so timely. I have needed a new makeup remover. And I happen to have witch hazel in the cupboard. I think I will try it with coconut oil. That may also help keep it shelf stable longer.