This recipe is one that I’ve had numerous requests for since I developed it. So if you’ve been waiting for it – here it is!
And I’ve been making way too much of it :-).
It really is that good – and that easy.
My family’s Baked Oatmeal Cake obsession all started when our dear friend, Becky, shared some baked oatmeal with us at her home one night after a homeschooling family gathering. I had heard of baked oatmeal, but had never made it nor tried it. Well, my kids gobbled it up and ….well, I was then one a quest for the best Baked Oatmeal recipe that I could find.
I came home with her recipe in hand and poked around on the internet a bit and found a few recipes that intrigued me, but I basically ended up altering a combination of my friend’s recipe and this one from Baked Bree.
The resulting success story that you see pictured above is the result!
I love this cake – why? It is:
- Super easy
- Super healthy
- Super good
The funny thing about this recipe is that I discovered the “cake” version completely by mistake. I knew it was important to soak grains (especially oats) and so I set the oats out to soak overnight.
The next day ended up being a flurry of too many things to do and so I didn’t get around to baking the cake until about 24 hours later. The result? A delicious not-too-sweet-at-all cake that you won’t believe was made entirely from rolled oats. (For another “mistake turned family favorite, see my post on Chat Masala.)
You can make the oatmeal cake in either way (hence the funny title), either soaking the oats just overnight so that you end up with more of a Baked Oatmeal-type dish. The top will be more of a cake, but it will be more dense and more like thick oatmeal on the bottom.
Or, if you soak them for 24 hours or more (like I did the first time :-)), then you will end up with something that more resembles a cake than baked oatmeal.
In fact, when I took the 24 hour soaked version over to Becky’s house for her to try, she said, “You added flour to this, didn’t you?”
No – I didn’t :-). The oats just turned out that way. Amazing. See how much soaking your grains can change the grains themselves?
Don’t know about soaking grains? I never had heard of this until a few years ago and I didn’t really understand. The basic reason is that grains (and especially oats) contain phytic acid and other anti-nutrients that make digestion difficult. You can read more about this in my post on how and why to soak grains.
We like this recipe both ways, but I personally think the cake version is a bit nicer.
Note: Some links that follow are affiliate links. If you click on them and make a purchase, I might make a commission. Your price does not change, however–thanks for your support of my blog :)! My full disclaimer is here.
Baked Oatmeal (or Oatmeal Cake) (dairy, egg, gluten and sugar-free options)
Makes 9-12 servings. (Depending on size, of course :-))
4 cups rolled oats (use gluten free oats if necessary)
4 cups milk (or non-dairy substitute. My Easiest Coconut Milk would work great!)
6 Tbsp coconut oil, melted (or other healthy fat alternative – use applesauce for a THM E menu option)
1/3 cup granulated sweetener (use xylitol or erythritol for ACD friendly. Or sub a liquid sweetener using my guidelines in Substituting Sweeteners.)
3 scoops (1/32 tsp each) stevia extract or additional 1/3 cup granulated sweetener
1 tsp salt (I recommend Real Salt)
1 Tbsp cinnamon
2 eggs (or egg substitute. See my Powdered Egg Substitute.)
2 tsp baking powder (See Homemade Baking Powder)
4 tsp vanilla
1 cup nuts (optional)
1 cup fresh or dried fruit (optional)
Cinnamon Sugar (optional) for topping (See my Healthier Cinnamon Sugar.)
1. Mix oats, milk, and sweeteners in a large bowl. Soak either overnight (for a more baked oatmeal-type dish) or for at least 24 hours (for an Oatmeal Cake) at room temperature.
2. Add remaining ingredients, saving baking powder and egg substitute (if using) until last.
3. Mix well.
4. If using nuts and/or dried or fresh fruit, put half of the nuts and fruit in the bottom of a greased 8×8 square baking dish.
5. Pour the batter onto the nuts and fruit (or directly into the prepared dish if not using the nuts and fruit).
6. Top with the remaining nuts and/or fruit if using.
7. Top with Cinnamon Sugar if desired.
8. Bake in a preheated 375 degree oven for 35-45 minutes, or until the middle of the cake is set.
9. Serve either warm, with additional Cinnamon Sugar, nuts, fruit and milk (almond milk and coconut milk are wonderful on top) or eat at room temperature like a cake.
10. Store in the refrigerator in a closed container.
1. I make this regularly with walnuts and dried apples we made in our dehydrator. So many combinations are possible. Bananas and walnuts, fresh apples and pecans…We even once just blended shredded coconut (about 1/3 cup) into the batter and sprinkled both cinnamon sugar and more coconut on top. It was wonderful.
2. As mentioned above, you can use any type of milk that you like. I recommend healthy raw milk if you use dairy. Otherwise, any non dairy alternative will work great.
3. As with any tried and true recipe, I recommend Baking in Bulk to save time and money. I’ve made the mistake of baking new recipes in bulk before (and then I end up with way too much of something we may not like). But now I’m getting better at “new recipe restraint” and so now I just bulk bake with the recipes that we love. I typically mix up and soak 4 batches of this cake at time!
I think this would make a wonderful Christmas morning treat!
Other Healthy Baked Goods:
- Baked Cinnamon Doughnuts
- Pumpkin Snickerdoodles
- Super Quick Whole Grain Biscuits (all with allergy-friendly options)
Do you have a favorite Christmas morning recipe?
Or a recipe “mistake” that turned out great?